The hidden rules behind YouTube In-stream, In-feed, and Shorts that decide if your ads win or die 👀

This guide breaks down the role of each placement, how they function, and what kind of creative tends to work best for each one.

1. In-stream: The “Control the first 5 seconds” format

In-stream ads autoplay before or during YouTube videos. They take over the full screen, and the viewer has to watch at least five seconds before they can skip. Those first five seconds are your window to earn attention.

This format gives you more room to breathe than Shorts or In-feed ads. There are fewer distractions — especially when running on big screens like connected TVs. That’s where in-stream shines. We’ve seen 20+ minute VSLs outperform short-form because they matched the moment: device, mindset, and audience.

For example, a 26-minute VSL we ran for an older-skewing DTC offer outperformed all our short-form tests by 2x on connected TVs. It wasn’t flashier. It just fit the format better.

Evening viewers on TV aren’t in scroll mode. They’re leaning back, open to stories. When the creative feels like content, not a pitch, they stick around.

That said, mobile isn’t an afterthought. We’ve had great results with vertical In-stream ads under 2 minutes, targeted specifically to mobile devices. These fill the screen, feel native, and convert well — especially top-of-funnel.

Bottom line: the format works when you match the story to the screen.

2. In-feed: The “Click-earned” format

In-feed ads show up on the YouTube homepage, in search results, and next to related videos. They don’t autoplay. The viewer has to decide whether to click.

That decision hinges entirely on the thumbnail and title. You're not buying impressions — you're earning them. That shifts your strategy from "interrupt" to "invite."

If the creative looks staged, corporate, or overly polished, it usually gets passed over. The best-performing in-feed ads follow native YouTube patterns: real people, a natural tone, and content that feels like it’s delivering value upfront.

Once someone clicks, expectations rise. You’ve earned their attention, but now you have to hold it. The first few seconds need to prove the click was worth it.

Length-wise, 60 to 90 seconds often works well. But structure and tone matter more than runtime. Make it feel like something the viewer chose to watch — because they did.

3. Shorts: The “No sound, no second chance” format

Shorts are vertical videos under 60 seconds that autoplay in YouTube’s swipeable feed. There’s no title or thumbnail — the video speaks for itself, instantly.

This is the fastest-scroll environment on YouTube. Attention spans are short, and users can swipe away in a heartbeat. Creatives need to hook visually within the first second.

Motion, bold visuals, and quick framing win here. Assume the sound is off. Voiceover-only intros fail. Strong visual storytelling is essential.

Shorts aren’t ideal for complex messaging. Their power is in reach and quick engagement — not depth. Use them to spark curiosity at the top of the funnel, then retarget with deeper content.

Respect the format, win the placement

Each YouTube placement operates by different rules. They reflect different viewer behaviors, contexts, and content expectations. Treating them the same is the fastest way to waste creative.

Before your next campaign, ask: Does this ad match the mindset of the scroll it’s interrupting?

When you match your video to the format, screen, and mindset, performance follows.

Respect the format. It's how you win the placement.

💌 Like this newsletter? Let's continue the conversation

Get in touch with us by responding to this email or tagging us on LinkedIn or Instagram and sharing your thoughts. Your feedback helps us keep our newsletter relevant and interesting.